Mental Health & Isolation Forum

What this board is for

The part nobody warns you about: loneliness, cabin fever, the winter dip, the strain that a build year puts on a relationship, and the adjustment that comes with quiet and distance. It is a board for honest conversation rather than for advice-giving, and it is one of the more valuable ones here for exactly that reason.

Nothing on this board is clinical advice. Where something is persistent or serious, a clinician is the right answer, and telemedicine has made that considerably more accessible from remote addresses than it used to be.

What comes up most

The winter dip. Short days, outdoor work, and a demanding routine combine into something a lot of people experience in their first northern winter and few expect. It is common, it is not a character failure, and there are ordinary effective responses.

Loneliness that is not about wanting a crowd. Distance removes casual contact rather than deliberate contact, and the absence of incidental human interaction is what people describe missing rather than parties.

Relationship strain in year one. Usually about workload distribution and unmet expectations rather than about the life itself, and usually improved a great deal by naming it early.

The gap between the imagined version and the actual one. Almost universal, rarely discussed, and worth discussing.

What a useful post looks like here

Say as much or as little as you want. This is the one board where a question without technical specifics is entirely appropriate, and where the useful responses are experiences rather than answers.

If you are responding to somebody, resist the urge to solve it. Most of what helps here is somebody saying that they felt the same thing and that it passed, or did not pass until they changed something specific.

What people say actually helps

Getting outside in daylight, deliberately, particularly in the months when the work is indoors and the light is short. Keeping at least one social commitment that has a schedule, so that contact does not depend on motivation.

Finishing something. Living permanently among unfinished projects wears on people, and completing one room or one system properly changes how the whole place feels.

Talking about the division of labor explicitly rather than letting it settle by default. And treating the first year as temporary, because it is: the households that describe the life fondly are usually describing year three rather than year one.

The mistakes that cost the most here

Toughing it out on the theory that this is what you signed up for. Seasonal low mood in particular responds to ordinary measures and does not respond to endurance.

Letting social contact become entirely incidental, so that it stops when the weather does.

Assuming the person you are doing this with is fine because they have not said otherwise. In year one, nobody has time to raise anything that is not urgent.

Cutting off from people who are not doing this, on the grounds that they will not understand. They may not, and they are still your people.

And carrying on when something is clearly beyond a rough patch, rather than talking to a clinician.

The relationship version of this

The strongest predictor of how a first year goes is whether both people wanted the same life or one wanted it and the other was being agreeable. Agreeableness holds up in July and does not hold up in a February week when the inverter is faulting and the road is a rut.

The practical measures are unglamorous: divide the departments explicitly and in specific terms, agree what a day off looks like and take it, and schedule the conversation about how it is going rather than waiting for it to arrive as an argument.

It is also worth noticing who has become the default for everything mechanical, because that person will feel it, and the person who cannot fix things will feel that too.

How much of this is regional

Latitude matters, because winter daylight varies enormously and the northern version of the winter dip is a different intensity from the southern one. So does the culture of the area: some rural communities are highly social and some are not, and arriving in the second kind expecting the first is disorienting.

Distance to any kind of clinical support varies too, and telemedicine availability depends on connectivity, which is why the connectivity board is relevant to this one.

None of that changes the basic advice, which is to take it seriously and not alone.

Where this meets the rest of the site

The community board is the outward-facing version of the same subject, and building a local network is the measure that most reliably helps. The journal section on isolation covers the winter dip and the first-year adjustment in more depth.

Lesson one of the course is deliberately honest about the mental weight of quiet and distance, because deciding with your eyes open is what makes the difference.

And if you are in the middle of it right now, saying so here is a reasonable thing to do.

The lesson that covers this

Lesson 12: The first year, and the shakedown in the free course works through this subject in the order the decisions actually arrive. Move in with a sequence, test every system before winter, and know what breaks first so the second year is easier.

The whole course is twelve lessons, free, with no account required to read any of it: start at the beginning if you are new to this, or jump straight to the lesson above if you are not.

Tools for this topic

Most questions on this board come down to a number somebody has not worked out yet. These do the arithmetic and show their working, so an answer here can be checked rather than taken on faith.

• Tools: every calculator on the site
• Learn: the free twelve-lesson course
• Off grid laws: what your county permits

How this board works

Posting needs an account, which exists so that answers have a name attached and so that the same person can be asked a follow-up six months later. It costs nothing and it is not used for anything else.

The conventions here are the ones that make a small forum useful. Say where you are, at least to the state or region, because almost every answer on this site depends on climate or on local rules. Say what you have already, and what you have already tried. Give numbers where you have them, and say when you are guessing. And when something works or fails, come back and say which, because the thread is read by far more people than post in it.

Answers here should be able to say where they came from. Experience is welcome and so is a rule of thumb, as long as it is labeled as one. Where a claim is about safety, code, or law, it wants a source, because the reader on the other end may be about to spend money or wire something themselves.

Boards next door

Off-grid questions rarely stay inside one department. A water question is often a power question underneath, and a land question is usually several at once. These boards field the neighboring subjects:

• Community & Finding Others: You do not have to do it alone: meeting rural neighbors, vetting intentional communities, group buys and mutual aid, and...
• Family & Kids: Raising a family off-grid: homeschooling, kids and socialization, getting a reluctant partner on board, and sharing the ...
• Transition & First-Year: What the first year off-grid is really like: honest timelines, the mistakes almost everyone makes, easing in instead of ...
• Health & First Aid: Staying healthy far from a hospital: first-aid and trauma kits, remote medical skills, telehealth, prescriptions, and a ...

Asking a question that gets a good answer

The difference between a thread that gets three useful replies and one that gets none is almost always in the first post. Four things do most of the work: where you are, what you already have, what you have already tried, and what you are actually trying to achieve.

Location matters because nearly every answer on this site depends on climate or on local rules, and the same question has different right answers in Vermont and Arizona. What you have matters because advice that assumes different equipment wastes everyone's time. What you have tried stops people repeating it. And the goal matters because the best answer is frequently that the problem should be solved somewhere else entirely: a load reduced rather than a battery added, a parcel checked rather than a design revised.

Numbers beat adjectives. Give the figure where you have one and say plainly when you are guessing, because a guess labeled as a guess is useful and a guess presented as a measurement sends people down the wrong path.

Answering well, and the standard here

Experience is the most valuable thing on a board like this, and it is most valuable when it comes with its conditions attached: what you have, where, for how long, and what went wrong along the way. A rule of thumb is welcome when it is labeled as one.

Where a claim is about safety, code, or law, it wants a source, because the person reading may be about to wire something themselves or spend a large amount of money. Direct-current faults, combustion appliances, and structural decisions are not places for confident approximations, and saying you are not sure is a genuine contribution rather than a failure.

It is also worth saying when something has changed. Equipment, prices, and regulations all move, and an answer that was right three years ago can be wrong now.

Coming back with what happened

The most underused post on any forum is the follow-up. Threads are read by far more people than post in them, and a question with no resolution is a question the next reader has to ask again.

So come back and say which suggestion worked, what it cost, and what you would do differently. Say it even when the answer is that none of the advice helped and you solved it another way, because that is the most useful outcome of all to record.

If what you learned contradicts something published on this site, please say so. Corrections are logged publicly on the corrections page with the date rather than quietly edited away, and readers who have called the county or walked the ground are the best source of correction this site has.

All boards · Create an account · The journal · The course